Showing posts with label matt damon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label matt damon. Show all posts

Jun 22, 2014

The Monuments Men

My wife is on nights at the hospital, so that means it is time for another round of “David Catches Up on Movies!” Last time, I watched some sci-fi films that I had managed to miss. This time, I am just grabbing anything that piques my interest.  I was again too tired on Wednesday night to watch a movie.  And after my lack of appreciation for the violent films, I decided to pick up "The Monuments Men" with George Clooney and a ton of other people.


I like George Clooney.  I mean, I don't know him or anything.  But I like him as an actor and entertainment personality.  One of my favorite movie franchises is the Oceans trilogy.  I have enjoyed several Clooney starring, directed, or produced projects (Good Night and Good Luck, The Descendants, Leatherheads, Up in the Air, Out of Sight).  I also like the fact that he is concerned about the world around him.  So whenever Clooney is involved in something, it immediately gains my attention.


I like Matt Damon.  Again, I don't know the guy personally.  I enjoy his movies.  Obviously, I am a big fan of Oceans.  I've also loved Damon in We Bought a Zoo, the Bourne Trilogy, The Good Shepherd, True Grit.  He's a good actor.  In addition, he also is very interested in helping the world around him.  Which is great.

I like Bill Murray.  One of my favorite movies is Groundhog Day.  I think Murray is a severely under appreciated actor.  I like John Goodman.  I like Cate Blanchett.  You see where this is going.  When I saw the marketing for The Monuments Men, it seemed like a surefire hit.  The cast is astounding.  Clooney directed it.  It is set in World War II, which has such a rich depth of available stories.  And there appeared to be a kind of Oceans Eleven vibe to it.  The previews seemed pretty humorous.  "'I appear to have stepped on a land mine.'  'Well what did you do that for?'"  And I mean, look at the tagline for the movie.  "It was the greatest art heist in history."  Good stuff, right?

Then I finally got to watch The Monuments Men.  I honestly felt like the movie suffered from the same problem that Clooney himself suffers from.  I never know when to take the film, or the actor, seriously.  Clooney has that little smirk, even when he is isn't in a funny movie.  I have had a hard time in some of his stuff because he doesn't really have an intensity switch.  The movie itself had the same problem.  Was it a lighthearted take on a marginal element of World War II?  Or was it something more serious?  

If you look at the cast, it is heavily loaded with actors very comfortable with comedy: Goodman, Murray, Clooney, Bob Balaban (Friends, Christopher Guest movies), Jean Dujardin (The Artist), even Damon.  The previews were heavy on the comedic elements.  The score by Alexandre Desplat had this kind of playful quality.  It seemed to be written for a old-school farce or something.  All of that is swirling around against the backdrop of the horrors of war.  

Then there was another problem, one that the characters IN the film seemed to wrestle with most of the time.  These guys were scampering around Europe trying to save works of art while there were millions of people trying to, you know, not die.  World War II saw some of the worst atrocities in human history.  The violence was so brutal (referring back to Saving Private Ryan, mentioned in my post the other day).  Concentration camps, ethnic cleansing, internment camps, atomic bombs, relentless bombing, starvation.  War is despicable.  World War II was beyond despicable.  As these artists are racing around, they try to get help from "real soldiers."  These war weary men look at the artists like they are crazy.  One officer responds to a request help with, "I know exactly what you want.  You want me to tell my guys, who are trying to fight off an enemy force, to risk being killed by not blowing up certain buildings."  It really was ludicrous.  

But, on the other hand, you could understand what these guys were saying as well.  Hitler didn't just want to win the war or take over the world.  He didn't even want to just kill the Jews.  He wanted to erase them from history.  Clooney's character keeps saying that it is important to preserve the culture of a people as well.  They make good points.  But, as one commenter on imdb.com said, "Who cares.  Twelve million people died."  Point taken.
The movie would be humming along, these guys sparring with and razzing each other.  Then, all of the sudden, someone would get killed.  Or they would find giant barrels full of gold teeth pulled out of the mouths of Jewish people killed by the Germans.  Then they would go back to goofing around.  Then they would rush some guy into a battlefield hospital who was destroyed by artillery fire.  Then they would flirt with a French resistance fighting artist.  It was weird.  

I have had a couple of days to think about the movie.  And I still don't really know what exactly Clooney was trying to do with the film.  Were we supposed to sympathize with the artists and their quest to save over three million pieces of art?  Or were we supposed to think that their efforts were juvenile when compared with the massive cost of the war?  There were times when it felt like these guys were being mocked by the movie itself - putting a huge discovery of art in juxtaposition with the barrels of teeth, for example.  At other times, it was clear that they were the heroes, protecting what no one else realized was even important.  But even the overall villainy wasn't clear.  Hitler was the ultimate bad guy.  He was the one behind all of the atrocities - the destruction, the Jewish persecution, the theft and/or destruction of tons of irreplaceable artwork.  But, the most tense moments in the film came when these artists were faced with a confrontation with the Soviets, who were planning on taking all the Nazi-stolen art back to Russia to make up for their losses.  And the people that raised the most ire for me were actually the allied military leaders who completely ignored the Monuments Men's warnings about several dangers, which led to the deaths of multiple people.  Again, it was weird.

Needless to say, I was very disappointed with the film.  It was extremely uneven in tone and message.  The acting was nice.  It was like having a good time with friends, chatting and hanging out.  Then those fun times were punctuated by shockingly horrific events.  Only, then we were expected to just go back to having a good time.  Why?  That's the question I was left asking.  Were we supposed to take on a bigger message, like how easily it is to just forget the horrors of the world around us in favor of what we see as important?  That makes me feel like the Monuments Men were completely misguided in their efforts.  Or were we supposed to realize that the cost of war is more than just lives and structural damage, but also the heart, souls, and culture of the people involved?  In that case, the soldier artists were definitely heroes.  I desperately wanted to like the film.  I wanted to see it as important.  But it felt like the movie itself kept me from succeeding in my mission.

Jul 16, 2012

Spy vs Spy

My wife is out of town for the week.  So that means that I'm bored.  Instead of watching the shows stacking up on my DVR (all of which my wife wants to see), I am hitting up the Red Box and catching up on some movies that I have not been able to see yet.  To make this even more fun, I will be blogging my reviews and thoughts about the films.  First up: Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy.


Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy is an old-fashioned spy thriller.  I mean, not just Hunt for Red October old-fashioned.  I mean really old-fashioned.  Set in 1973, it has virtually none of the trapping of a modern spy film.  It was kind of hard for my brain to transition to the different environment.  There were no cell phones, no computers, no surveillance cameras on every corner.  Instead, the spies used pay phones and read paper briefings.  Rather than using high-powered assault rifles, homemade bombs, and specialized training these spies relied on knives, pistols, and hunting rifles.  But their biggest weapon was their words.

I never had really thought about how much spies in older spy movies were so dependent on words.  They were everything.  That was how you transmitted information, organized plans, turned enemies.  Words were the most valuable commodity around.  Sometimes, that was the ultimate goal - to hear just a simple word.  A code, a mission name, an operative's handle, a target location.  Just a single word could have massive, long-term ramifications for hundreds of people.  In Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, one agent was broken through enemy interrogation and he sold out all the operatives in an area.  He asked if they had gotten out okay, only to find that his words had betrayed every one of them.  Words had meaning.  


I had seen in several reviews of the film that the dialogue was critical and was hard to follow.  I understand why people would say that.  I had to have my television's volume about fifty percent higher than normal just to catch everything (which made for a shock when a pistol would go off).  I don't think the movie itself was to blame.  Rather, it is more a commentary on how we, as moviegoers, have become so accustomed to noise.  That is where there is the greatest contrast between Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy and modern spy offerings.  When I think of the modern spy genre, immediately I think of the Bourne series.  It also includes the newer Bond movies, shows like Burn Notice and Covert Affairs, and films like Salt or Mr. and Mrs. Smith or Mission: Impossible.  In these stories, the modern spy is still brilliant and deductive.  But they also are like real-life superheroes.


Think about Jason Bourne or Michael Westen.  They know how to use every weapon: knives of all sizes, grenade launchers, rail guns.  They are trained in all sorts of combat - from Asian martial arts to parkour.  They are military geniuses.  In addition, they are all super sexy and use seduction as a common technique.  They also have super spidey senses, able to tell if the smallest item is moved or if a person breathes two rooms away.  Words are not as important as trickery and acting.  Technology is deeply interwoven into the modern spy's repertoire.  He or she must be able to hack into any computer, clone drives, nullify unbelievably intricate security systems, hijack the local network of cameras, and edit videos on the fly.  


Looking at the difference between the Bourne series and Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy is an interesting exercise.  Both films are very good.  They are well written and executed.  They attract amazing casts.  Think about the names that were in those films.  The Bourne films have Oscar and Golden Globe nominees and winners galore.  Matt Damon, Jeremy Renner, Edward Norton, Chris Cooper, Albert Finney, David Strathairn, Joan Allen, Clive Owen, Scott Glenn, and Brian Cox all have acting hardware on their shelves.  Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy can easily match that roster (as well as show their apparent affinity for grabbing Harry Potter cast members.  Gary Oldman, Colin Firth, John Hurt, and Toby Jones all have been acknowledged by those groups - while other cast members Benedict Cumberbatch, Tom Hardy, and Mark Strong will almost assuredly be nominated at some point in the near future.  


Interestingly, they both tell the tales of a spy disillusioned by their role and their leaders.  It is pretty common for modern American cinema to wallow in the anti-establishment end of the pond.  Most Americans don't trust their government and believe there are conspiracies afoot.  So it is only natural for the modern brilliant spy to uncover the nefarious plots.  Apparently a few decades back, the British intelligence community was as highly regarded as a circa 1990s American automobile.  So the more alert operatives in that group were hitting the same place that modern US operatives are now.  The themes of betrayal, corruption, misguided methods, and blind ambition run through both works.  For all of their similarities, though, these two examples go about things in a completely different way.


Jason Bourne is a man of few words.  But he is a man of action.  Gary Oldman's George Smiley is also a man of few words - at first.  I clocked it last night.  Even though he was in virtually every scene in the first part of the movie, Smiley didn't talk until the 18 minute mark.  At that point, he mostly spoke in minor phrases, spending most of his time thinking, analyzing, and plotting.  As the movie progressed, though, Smiley spoke more and more.  Bourne, as the movies progressed, would demonstrate his physical brilliance in fending off increasingly dangerous attacks.  Smiley showed his mental brilliance as he maneuvered through the web of lies all around him.  Instead of breaking out into violence, he wielded his words like a sword - both to inspire loyalty from those close to him and to strike fear into those plotting against him.  He pulled a gun once, but never actually USED a weapon.  A far cry from a modern spy.  


There were no car chases, no explosions.  There were few, if any, fight scenes.  There was violence.  It was crude and awful - which made it all the more shocking.  So many times in modern action movies, people die and property gets destroyed at such a rate that we rarely blink an eye when someone gets offed.  In fact, going into a film like Bourne, we expect that two-thirds of the people will probably end up dead.  I kept waiting for the wholesale clearing house scene in Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy.  It never happened.  Each death that was shown was brutal and affecting.  It really brings home the fact that taking a life weighs on a person.  You could see that weight etched on the faces of each person.  The younger spies were overwhelmed by the pain of loss as they experienced it for the first time.  The older spies had a weary look of acceptance, but the pain didn't disappear.  


Another example of this genre of film would be The Good Shepherd.  It was a modern film that looked at the beginning of the CIA.  Matt Damon played another word-sparing spy.  But this time it was in a different world.  Gone were the images of Damon beating a man up with a magazine and blowing up an apartment complex with a microwave.  The spy in Shepherd was coldly calculating.  I could actually see that character growing up into Oldman's George Smiley.  They were cut from the same cloth and spies of a similar era.


I think both types of movies have their place.  I love sitting back and watching Michael Westen blow up half of Miami without any consequences.  It is fun.  Westen is brilliant and talented.  So is Jason Bourne.  I am excited about Bourne Legacy.  I loved the first three movies.  They are exciting and riveting.  But Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy is a different kind of movie.  It is slow and thoughtful.  It requires the viewer and the spy to pay attention to everything.  There is nothing loud and explosive to distract and thrill.  Instead there is just the enjoyment of watching a master at work.  


Part of that mastery is found in Gary Oldman's portrayal of the elder spy.  Personally, I think Oldman is one of the most brilliant actors out there.  He is a complete chameleon.  He makes every role his own to the point that you can't imagine anyone else being cast.  JFK's Lee Harvey Oswald, Dracula's vampire prince, Fifth Element's wacko Zorg, Harry Potter's Sirius Black - even Batman's Commissioner Gordon.  (I am a massive Batman fan and when I heard Oldman was cast as Gordon, I just about wet myself with excitement.)  I have always found it more difficult for actors to portray a quiet character than a loud one.  I am nowhere near as impressed by Al Pacino's Scent of a Woman or Oceans Thirteen performance as a I am by his Godfather or  Insomnia ones.  I think actors love to portray over-the-top characters because they are so showy and noticeable.  It is easy to overlook someone quiet and thoughtful.  But the ability to imbue that person with layers and depth takes work.  You can't rely on a big speech to flesh out your character.  It is in a glance or a sigh.  That actually is also why I think Matt Damon is such a good actor.  His Jason Bourne and Good Shepherd character both carried that ability to say enough by saying nothing at all.  


That all being said, I enjoyed Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy.  It was tense and engaging.  I loved the performances by everyone - especially Oldman, Tom Hardy (brilliant in its restraint) and Cumberbatch.  [Side note: Tomorrow's post will deal more with him as I compare the Sherlock Holmes movies with the BBC Sherlock show.  Spoiler alert: I think Cumberbatch is a brilliant megastar on the rise.]  I appreciate a movie that make me think and doesn't rely on action sequences all the time.  It was a throwback, which I appreciate from time to time.  Maybe its because I remember the era the movie was set in, when spies were these mysterious characters in an invisible war instead of superheros fighting nothing in particular.